Forum:February Patch: Difference between revisions

From Drunkapedia
Jump to: navigation, search
imported>An Adventurer
No edit summary
imported>Sanddh
 
(55 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 63: Line 63:


--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 02:27, 25 January 2012 (EST)
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 02:27, 25 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::
| Text = Weapon template sandbox updated, If that's good then i'm going to move the changes over prior to the patch so we dont have to hammer the wiki while lots of users are trying to access after patch.
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::
| Text = I poked around in the code a bit. You can see my test page on [[User:An Adventurer/Sandbox 2]].
* Removed the weapon type options for bow/xbow/tw. No idea why they were in the melee weapon template.
* moved Two Handed from Weapon Type to Weapon Skill.
* Updated wield/buffed wield reqs to display Weapon Skill instead of Weapon Type.
I noticed a few errors with this. When you set Weapon Skill to "Heavy" for example, it just displays as ''Your base Heavy must be at least 250 to wield this item.'' So, we either need to make sure we always use the exact skill name for this variable, or have it set up so putting in Heavy/HW/Heavy Weapon will all display "Heavy Weapon Skill," or whatever the skills will be called.
<br />
On that note, Could some please make a post on the turbine boards requesting, on behalf of the wiki, for the exact names of the new skills? This would make pre-patch work so much easier. I'd do it, but I cannot post on their forums without an active account, or even use private messages. Way to go turbine.
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 02:23, 26 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::::
| Text = Seems the stats panels for quest weapons not only reflect the skill, but also refer to the "Mastery". See [[Talk:Royal Runed Knuckles]] for an example. I don't know (yet) if this is the case for all quest weapons, but maybe there could be an option added to the melee template to reflect this? ----[[User:Sanddh|Sanddh]] 06:12, 22 February 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::
| Text = I sent a PM to Sev, hopefully he responds. --[[User:Immortalbob|Immortalbob]] 15:24, 26 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::
| Text = Heavy Weapons<br />
Light Weapons<br />
Finesse Weapons<br />
Sneak Attack<br />
Dual Wield<br />
Recklessness<br />
Dirty Fighting<br />
Shield --[[User:Immortalbob|Immortalbob]] 10:16, 27 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::::
| Text = Well, while that is helpful, its certainly a bit of a pain for the wiki. We previously went with, for example, [[Sword]] for the skill and [[Swords]] for the weapons. If [[Heavy Weapons]] is the skill name that takes the name for the item page. We'll have to come up with something else, I guess.
I'm curious, could you ask if the skill "Two Handed Combat" is changing to "Two Handed Weapons" to match the naming convention?
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 10:40, 27 January 2012 (EST)
edit: Also, Missile Weapons is not in your list. Is that skill still planned for feb and can you see about confirming the name for that one?
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 10:44, 27 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::::
| Text = In the list section, I've changed the skills to be the exact name of the skill, and the weapon listing pages are now "List of <type> Weapons"
Two reasons for this:
# We've been trying to avoid having articles end in parentheses (for easier external linking) and I had already removed the (Skill) from most/all skill pages.
# The skill name is in game, where as the list of weapons is on the wiki only. For naming purposes, in-game trumps wiki only.
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 01:24, 28 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::
| Text = "Missile Weapons" confirmed. --[[User:Immortalbob|Immortalbob]] 23:30, 27 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::
| Text = Preliminary working page for all those weapon sets we have on the wiki, those need to be reworked too... [[User:Sanddh/Sandbox]] Going for a sortable table for now, since that might be easiest especially with the more complicated weapons such as the palenqual and renegade palenqual.
--[[User:Sanddh|Sanddh]] 22:30, 27 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::
| Text = Another thing to start thinking about now:
So, every weapon entry we have, except possibly some 2H weapons, is going to have a retired version (The current version using current skills). What are we going to do about retired versions of weapons that are still in the game, and I assume have to be updated to use the new skills? The first weapon that comes to mind is the [[Sword of Lost Light]].
All of the info on [[Sword of Lost Light (Retired)]] would be moved to [[Sword of Lost Light (Retired 1)]]. And all of the info on [[Sword of Lost Light]] would be moved to [[Sword of Lost Light (Retired 2)]]. But what about those old school SoLLs that are still in the game? I assume they'll have to use Heavy Weapon Skill, since Sword won't exist. How do we handle an updated version of a retired item?
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 02:44, 25 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::
| Text = Regarding newly retired weapons, (Retired 1/2) works for me. For updated current retired items it's probably gonna only be damage/skill changes.  Those can be easily added to the notes section. --[[User:Immortalbob|Immortalbob]] 11:53, 25 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::
| Text = Scratch that, Retired pages are generally used for items that still "exist" but are obtainable only via trade (with exception to rares). Why not just notate the old damage in the Notes section? --[[User:Immortalbob|Immortalbob]] 12:05, 25 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::
| Text = We don't really have any rules on when to make a retired version. For example, I think they added mana c mods to all quest wands a long time ago, but we dont have both the pre and post patch as different versions. I guess a general rule could be, if the individual item was specifically targeted for an update (like, for example, the green mire grave updates and the changes to the Yari) it is a new version, but if its general updates like this across a wide range of weapons, its a stat tweak.
So, I think your idea sounds fine. If it is a retired version of a weapon that is still in the game (e.g. old model SoLL), and they just changed the skill/upped the dmg, then update the item entry and in the notes state "During the [[Feb 2012]] Event, the Skill to use this item was changed from Sword to Heavy Weapon, and the damage was changed from 10-20 to 12-24."
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 02:37, 26 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::
| Text = It might still be a good idea to archive the panel images, maybe have a retired version of the existing images on the "Discussion" tab, simply for historical reference. [[User:Atarax|Atarax]] 07:55, 26 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::::
| Text = I think not adding another retired version, but adding something to the note section is a better idea, since indeed none of the currently existing items will keep the current stats. However, we somehow have to keep track on which weapons have been updated to the new stats and which still need to be researched. Probably the more popular ones will be updated quickly, but others won't (think about all those different versions of the renegade palenqual weapons, yikes...)
<br>
I agree with keeping the old panel images, if only that until now, we are not even complete on those old stat panels, so it will probably take a long time to collect the new ones. However, to avoid confusion, is maybe an idea to write a bot (I am not able to I have to admit) which automatically puts a heading over any current (Melee & Missile) weapon stats panel in the discussion page with "pre-feb 2012" (or a sub-page)? That way we at least will know if a panel image has been updated or we still need to collect a new one. And I don't even want to think about all the quest armor which has some kind of weapon buff spell... --[[User:Sanddh|Sanddh]] 21:56, 27 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = :::::::
| Text = One way to keep track of which items have been updated is to use the currently linked spells as an index to what hasn't been changed yet.  For example, if I look up all items that fall into [[Special:WhatLinksHere/Sword_Mastery_Other_VI]], I know that anything listed hasn't been touched since there will be no items that have this spell anymore.  So going through all the items linked to obsolete spells should clear up a lot of items.  We would also need a way to handle items without spells (i.e. [[Cragstone's Axe]]), but have had their skill/requirements, or stats change as well. [[User:Atarax|Atarax]] 04:18, 28 January 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::::::::
| Text = Regarding the prepatch stats, rather than having to list the stats in the notes section you can link to a history page from before they were updated. For an example see [[Red Rune Silveran Staff]]. To get the link click the history tab and copy the link for the page before the stats were updated. --{{User:Tlosk/Sig}} 20:03, 1 March 2012 (EST)
}}
{{Post
| Indent = ::
| Text = Made a quick navigation bar for the new weapon skills - feel free to change it if you think it sucks. I thought we use some new icons as the previous ones were a little bit too oldschool hehe.
I subdivided some of the weapon set paged as was recommended and deleted the weapons from their quest pages as I don't think they should be listed there (see [[Isparian Weapons]]. I think it looks messy and it makes the weapon set pages kinda redundant also.
Thanks --[[User:Arkalor|Arkalor]] 14:45, 21 February 2012 (EST)
Edit: Icons with gold handles instead...
{{Weapon Links 3}}
Edit: Changed them again - made more sense to just use the spell icons:
{{Weapon Links}}
--[[User:Arkalor|Arkalor]] 04:43, 2 March 2012 (EST)
}}
== The List ==
Add items here that are missing, and '''Complete''' after items that have been updated/created.
{{Post
| Indent = ::
| Text = Here is a list of everything I can think of that will need to get updated:
'''Articles related to Item changes:'''
* [[Items]] - weapons section
** [[Weapons]] - possibly including the weapon sets links, to state which weapon uses which new skill
*** [[Finesse Weaponry]]
*** [[Heavy Weaponry]] <font color=green>(create)</font>
*** [[Light Weaponry]] <font color=green>(create)</font>
*** [[Missile Weaponry]] <font color=green>(create)</font>
*** [[Two Handed Weaponry]] - Move [[Two Handed Weapons]] to this page.
*** [[Axes]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Maces]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Swords]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Spears]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Daggers]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Staves]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Unarmed Weapons]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Bows]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Crossbows]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
*** [[Atlatls and Thrown Weapons]] <font color=red>(retire)</font>
* Every article for melee/missile weapons - The current pages need to archived as the retired versions, pages will need wiki template updates and new stats/skill reqs added
* [[Loot]] - This will need major revisions, and we will also want to archive current info somehow.
** Old weapon information archived [[Loot/Weapons Pre2012|here]].
** Temporary page for updating min/max stats [[Loot/Master of Arms Weapons|here]]. This will be moved to [[Loot]] once it's reasonably complete (separate page for now for database reasons).
'''Articles related to Skill changes:'''
* [[Skills]] - update both skill listings and racials, as those are going away
* [[Character Templates]] - Most of these templates will no longer be possible. They should be archived and new templates (including any new in-creation templates) should be added. (Stock Templates archived/updated)
* [[New Player Guide]] & [[Returning Player Guide]] - both of these are fairly incomplete and outdated anyway.
* Class Guides:
** [[Beginner's Guide to Playing an Archer]]
** [[Beginner's Guide to Playing a Mage]]
** [[Beginner's Guide to Playing a Warrior]]
** [[Advanced Guide to Playing an Archer]]
** [[Advanced Guide to Playing a Mage]]
** [[Advanced Guide to Playing a Warrior]]
* Quests/Content with heavy ties to skills being retired:
** [[Arm, Mind, Heart Quest]] - uses axe and spear for skill checks
** [[Atlan Weapons Quest]] - uses weapon skills for skill checks
** [[Composite Bow Quest]] - uses bow/xbow/tw for skill checks
** [[Harbinger Quest]]
** [[Heritage Masks]] - with racials going away, these masks should be checked for updates
** [[Isparian Weapons]] - uses weapon skills for skill checks
** [[Tier 1 Rares]]
** [[Spell Research]]
'''Page templates, wiki templates, misc'''
* [[Ammunition Template]] - possibly needs updating depending on what happens with missile weapons
* {{tl|Ammunition}} - possibly needs updating depending on what happens with missile weapons
* {{tl|Weapon Links}}
* [[MediaWiki:MenuSidebar]] (will need various links added and removed)
--[[User:An Adventurer|An Adventurer]] 06:00, 25 January 2012 (EST)
=== In Progress ===
* [[Weapon Mastery]] - Created, basic info from FAQ and forums added, needs specific effects added
'''Spells:'''
* [[Finesse Weapon Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>(created, needs checked for accuracy.</font>
* [[Finesse Weapon Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Heavy Weapon Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Heavy Weapon Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Light Weapon Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Light Weapon Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Missile Weapon Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Missile Weapon Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Dual Wield Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Dual Wield Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Dirty Fighting Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Dirty Fighting Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Recklessness Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Recklessness Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Sneak Attack Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Sneak Attack Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Shield Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
* [[Shield Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=green>created, needs checked, and updated for unconfirmed spells.</font>
=== Completed ===
''Skill Related''
* [[Attributes]] - Strength Coordination, and Quickness pages updated.
Skills:
** [[Finesse Weapons]] - icon, spell names, patch name, starting weapons added
** [[Heavy Weapons]] - icon, starting weapons, spell names, patch name, starting weapons added
** [[Light Weapons]] - icon, starting weapons, spell names, patch name, starting weapons added
** [[Missile Weapons]] - icon, starting weapons, spell names, patch name, starting weapons added
** [[Dual Wield]] - icon, spell names, patch name added
** [[Dirty Fighting]] - icon, spell names, patch name added
** [[Recklessness]] - icon, spell names, patch name added
** [[Sneak Attack]] - icon, spell names, patch name added
** [[Shield]] - icon, starting weapons, spell names, patch name, starting [[Round Shield]] added
** Updated other, existing skills:removed the old free skills
** [[Item Tinkering]] - merged with [[Gearcraft]]
** [[Axe]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Mace]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Sword]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Spear]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Dagger]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Staff]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Unarmed Combat]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Bow]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Crossbow]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Thrown Weapons]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
** [[Gearcraft]] <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Weapon Sets]] - each set subdivided into Magic, Missile, Heavy Melee, Light Melee and Finesse Melee Combat
''Templates/Categories''
* [[Melee Weapon Template]] - '''Complete''' Added new field to template page to reflect stats panel (Skill: Skill (Weapon Type) )
* [[Missile Weapon Template]] - '''Complete''' Added new field to template page to reflect stats panel (Skill: Missile Weapons (Weapon Type) )
* [[:Category:Missile Weapon]] '''Complete''' - Created
* [[:Category:Heavy Weapon]] '''Complete''' - Created
* [[:Category:Light Weapon]] '''Complete''' - Created
* [[:Category:Finesse Weapon]] '''Complete''' - Created
* {{tl|Melee Weapon}} - '''Complete''' - Live, all 600ish weapons listed in "Knowledge is Power" thread updated.
* {{tl|Missile Weapon}} - '''Complete''' Added [[:Category:Missile Weapon]] to top of template.
* {{tl|Skills}} - '''Complete''' Live
'''Spells:'''
* [[Axe Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Axe Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Bow Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Bow Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Crossbow Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Crossbow Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Dagger Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Dagger Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Mace Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Mace Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Spear Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Spear Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Staff Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Staff Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Sword Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Sword Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Thrown Weapons Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Thrown Weapons Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Unarmed Combat Ineptitude (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
* [[Unarmed Combat Mastery (Spell)]] and all sub-spells <font color=red>(retired)</font>
'''Articles related to Skill changes:'''
* Quests/Content with heavy ties to skills being retired:
** [[Bandit Hilt Quest]] - Retired as multi-strike property will drop in loot. Per NoWorries [http://forums.ac.turbine.com/showpost.php?p=614242&postcount=41]
** [[Bestowers' Guild of Dereth]] - no change, added a note concerning this.
** [[King Bobo]] - new Statues added, old ones classified as retired, old Reward Table archived on a subpage.
** [[Nuhmudira's Boon Quest]] - new amulets added and their effects
** [[Ruined Amulets]] - new amulets added, old ones classified as retired
** [[Skill Redistribution]] - new gems added, old ones classified as retired
** [[Sunstone and Opal Gauntlets Quest]] - new gaunts added (but not all have been found), old ones classified as retired
** [[Tesserae]] - updated with new Tesserae, old ones classified as retired.
** [[Rares#Spectral Mastery Crystals|Spectral Mastery Crystals]]
Character Creation:
* [[Character Creation]] - Race/Heritage and Skills sections will need updating '''Complete''' - added the new Masteries and removed the old free skills.
* [[Character Races]] '''Complete''' - added the new Masteries, removed the old free skills and the sister race skills
* [[Character Templates]] - "Stock Templates" - updated, old ones archived.
}}
}}

Latest revision as of 16:44, 6 March 2012

Forums: Index
General
Forum:February Patch


With the feb patch coming, so are a TON of changes to the wiki. We need to create spell pages for the new creature buff spells, remove/retire old weapon buff spell pages, update all old quest armor with a weapon skill buff to the new buff. All quest weapons/rares will need to be updated. Rare crystals will need to be retired/replaced. I think the weapons pages can stay separated since you will still aug one weapon type. These are just initial thoughts, anyone else? --Immortalbob 01:47, 24 January 2012 (EST)

It's going to be a lot of work. Hell, we haven't even finished updating all the quest/trophy experience values from the Learning From Experience patch over a year ago. And now every weapon entry is going to have to be redone, along with a ton of other stuff. Although I left for other reasons, I'm glad I got out when I did. The wiki and the game are gonna be a mess for quite some time.

Now, that said, I have a few suggestions:

Melee/Missile weapon templates:

  • Leave the " Weapon Type = " variable, since, as you said, there is supposed to be some aug for that.
  • On the missile weapon template, simply add [[Category:Missile Weapon]] to the template itself, if my understanding is correct that bow/xbow/TW are all being merged into Missile Weapon skill.
  • On the melee weapon template, add a new variable above weapon type, " Weapon Skill = " with the options being Heavy, Light, and Finesse. An automated find and replace could handle adding this variable (left blank) to every template, but getting the new skill type added will probably have to be done by hand.

Skills:

  • Update the table on the main skill page - should be simple enough.
  • Update the {{Skills}} template, replacing the Weapons section with Heavy/Light/Finesee/Missile
    • Optionally, add a "Retired" skills section at the bottom. Here we can list all the old item appraisal skills and the weapon skills.
  • Keep all the old skill pages around as historical references, but remove any skill categories so they do not get listed as currently available skills.

Spells:

  • Keep old weapon skill spells around, but remove categories. Treat them as retired, and add the new spell buffs.

Misc:

  • Anything that is no longer in the game due to these changes, e.g. weapon skill rare crystals, should be updated to be listed as retired.
  • Make sure to check changes to the Sunstone Gauntlets, Ruined Amulets, Title Bestower Guild, Skill Temples, and any other things that had something for every weapon skill. I have no idea how the devs are going to handle some of this stuff. Ruined Amulets for example have an amulet for each weapon skill, but these are turned in for life prots/attributes. Not sure how this will be handled after the changes.
  • Be sure to check out things that used weapon skills for a skill check. Atlans/Isparians, Composite Bow/Xbow/TW, crafting a few of the Arm, Mind, Heart items, and probably a few other things that aren't coming to mind right now.

Good luck to all the contributors that are still playing after Feb.

--An Adventurer 05:44, 24 January 2012 (EST)

I agree with all of this, we need a plan of attack... This may be what we need to work from as a list: [1] --Immortalbob 11:59, 24 January 2012 (EST)

A lot of things we need to know!! [2] --Immortalbob 12:14, 24 January 2012 (EST)

I've gone ahead and mocked up how i think the weapons list pages should sorta look post patch at User:Immortalbob/Sandbox using information in [3]. Also, I've made changes to the weapon template (now residing in Template:Sandbox) Ex: User:Immortalbob/Sandbox3. Any suggestions? --Immortalbob 13:52, 24 January 2012 (EST)

Oh, crap, I hadn't even thought of the weapon pages. I think those have to be completely redone. If we want the wiki to be organized the same way after the patch, that is, weapon listings based on the skill they use, we need to retire the Axes, Swords, etc pages and have Heavy Weapons, Light Weapons, Finesse Weapons, Missile Weapons, Two Handed Weapons (this is going more or less untouched, right?) and Thrown Weapons if they are not merging that with bow/xbow.

I have not been keeping up on all the details since I've quit, but from what I understand players are more likely to pick up one on the new combat skills and use all types of weapons (e.g. heavy weapons spec'd and using swords, maces, and axes) rather than picking up multiple skills and sticking to a single weapon type (e.g. trained/spec'd heavy/light/finesse and only using swords). So IMO it would make the most sense to list weapons by their new skill rather than by spec bonus.

Then on the new weapon skill pages, we'd add a new column "Weapon Type" for the specialization bonus weapon classes of Sword, Axe, Spear, etc.


As for your weapon template mock-up, looks good to me, I can only think of a few minor tweaks:

  1. Change the Category from "Heavy Combat" to "Heavy Combat Weapon". This goes with the naming convention we already have with Category:Two Handed Weapon, Category:Thrown Weapon, and Category:UA Weapon.
  2. Change the order the categories appear in so that they are listed as <Item Type> | <Weapon Skill> | <Specialization>, e.g.: Weapon | Heavy Combat Weapon | Axe.

--An Adventurer 02:27, 25 January 2012 (EST)

Weapon template sandbox updated, If that's good then i'm going to move the changes over prior to the patch so we dont have to hammer the wiki while lots of users are trying to access after patch.

I poked around in the code a bit. You can see my test page on User:An Adventurer/Sandbox 2.

  • Removed the weapon type options for bow/xbow/tw. No idea why they were in the melee weapon template.
  • moved Two Handed from Weapon Type to Weapon Skill.
  • Updated wield/buffed wield reqs to display Weapon Skill instead of Weapon Type.

I noticed a few errors with this. When you set Weapon Skill to "Heavy" for example, it just displays as Your base Heavy must be at least 250 to wield this item. So, we either need to make sure we always use the exact skill name for this variable, or have it set up so putting in Heavy/HW/Heavy Weapon will all display "Heavy Weapon Skill," or whatever the skills will be called.


On that note, Could some please make a post on the turbine boards requesting, on behalf of the wiki, for the exact names of the new skills? This would make pre-patch work so much easier. I'd do it, but I cannot post on their forums without an active account, or even use private messages. Way to go turbine. --An Adventurer 02:23, 26 January 2012 (EST)

Seems the stats panels for quest weapons not only reflect the skill, but also refer to the "Mastery". See Talk:Royal Runed Knuckles for an example. I don't know (yet) if this is the case for all quest weapons, but maybe there could be an option added to the melee template to reflect this? ----Sanddh 06:12, 22 February 2012 (EST)


I sent a PM to Sev, hopefully he responds. --Immortalbob 15:24, 26 January 2012 (EST)

Heavy Weapons
Light Weapons
Finesse Weapons
Sneak Attack
Dual Wield
Recklessness
Dirty Fighting
Shield --Immortalbob 10:16, 27 January 2012 (EST)

Well, while that is helpful, its certainly a bit of a pain for the wiki. We previously went with, for example, Sword for the skill and Swords for the weapons. If Heavy Weapons is the skill name that takes the name for the item page. We'll have to come up with something else, I guess.

I'm curious, could you ask if the skill "Two Handed Combat" is changing to "Two Handed Weapons" to match the naming convention?

--An Adventurer 10:40, 27 January 2012 (EST)

edit: Also, Missile Weapons is not in your list. Is that skill still planned for feb and can you see about confirming the name for that one?

--An Adventurer 10:44, 27 January 2012 (EST)

In the list section, I've changed the skills to be the exact name of the skill, and the weapon listing pages are now "List of <type> Weapons"

Two reasons for this:

  1. We've been trying to avoid having articles end in parentheses (for easier external linking) and I had already removed the (Skill) from most/all skill pages.
  2. The skill name is in game, where as the list of weapons is on the wiki only. For naming purposes, in-game trumps wiki only.

--An Adventurer 01:24, 28 January 2012 (EST)

"Missile Weapons" confirmed. --Immortalbob 23:30, 27 January 2012 (EST)

Preliminary working page for all those weapon sets we have on the wiki, those need to be reworked too... User:Sanddh/Sandbox Going for a sortable table for now, since that might be easiest especially with the more complicated weapons such as the palenqual and renegade palenqual. --Sanddh 22:30, 27 January 2012 (EST)


Another thing to start thinking about now:

So, every weapon entry we have, except possibly some 2H weapons, is going to have a retired version (The current version using current skills). What are we going to do about retired versions of weapons that are still in the game, and I assume have to be updated to use the new skills? The first weapon that comes to mind is the Sword of Lost Light.

All of the info on Sword of Lost Light (Retired) would be moved to Sword of Lost Light (Retired 1). And all of the info on Sword of Lost Light would be moved to Sword of Lost Light (Retired 2). But what about those old school SoLLs that are still in the game? I assume they'll have to use Heavy Weapon Skill, since Sword won't exist. How do we handle an updated version of a retired item?

--An Adventurer 02:44, 25 January 2012 (EST)

Regarding newly retired weapons, (Retired 1/2) works for me. For updated current retired items it's probably gonna only be damage/skill changes. Those can be easily added to the notes section. --Immortalbob 11:53, 25 January 2012 (EST)

Scratch that, Retired pages are generally used for items that still "exist" but are obtainable only via trade (with exception to rares). Why not just notate the old damage in the Notes section? --Immortalbob 12:05, 25 January 2012 (EST)

We don't really have any rules on when to make a retired version. For example, I think they added mana c mods to all quest wands a long time ago, but we dont have both the pre and post patch as different versions. I guess a general rule could be, if the individual item was specifically targeted for an update (like, for example, the green mire grave updates and the changes to the Yari) it is a new version, but if its general updates like this across a wide range of weapons, its a stat tweak.

So, I think your idea sounds fine. If it is a retired version of a weapon that is still in the game (e.g. old model SoLL), and they just changed the skill/upped the dmg, then update the item entry and in the notes state "During the Feb 2012 Event, the Skill to use this item was changed from Sword to Heavy Weapon, and the damage was changed from 10-20 to 12-24."

--An Adventurer 02:37, 26 January 2012 (EST)

It might still be a good idea to archive the panel images, maybe have a retired version of the existing images on the "Discussion" tab, simply for historical reference. Atarax 07:55, 26 January 2012 (EST)

I think not adding another retired version, but adding something to the note section is a better idea, since indeed none of the currently existing items will keep the current stats. However, we somehow have to keep track on which weapons have been updated to the new stats and which still need to be researched. Probably the more popular ones will be updated quickly, but others won't (think about all those different versions of the renegade palenqual weapons, yikes...)
I agree with keeping the old panel images, if only that until now, we are not even complete on those old stat panels, so it will probably take a long time to collect the new ones. However, to avoid confusion, is maybe an idea to write a bot (I am not able to I have to admit) which automatically puts a heading over any current (Melee & Missile) weapon stats panel in the discussion page with "pre-feb 2012" (or a sub-page)? That way we at least will know if a panel image has been updated or we still need to collect a new one. And I don't even want to think about all the quest armor which has some kind of weapon buff spell... --Sanddh 21:56, 27 January 2012 (EST)

One way to keep track of which items have been updated is to use the currently linked spells as an index to what hasn't been changed yet. For example, if I look up all items that fall into Special:WhatLinksHere/Sword_Mastery_Other_VI, I know that anything listed hasn't been touched since there will be no items that have this spell anymore. So going through all the items linked to obsolete spells should clear up a lot of items. We would also need a way to handle items without spells (i.e. Cragstone's Axe), but have had their skill/requirements, or stats change as well. Atarax 04:18, 28 January 2012 (EST)

Regarding the prepatch stats, rather than having to list the stats in the notes section you can link to a history page from before they were updated. For an example see Red Rune Silveran Staff. To get the link click the history tab and copy the link for the page before the stats were updated. --How often to wash makeup brushes? ,<a href=http://cheap-macmakeupor.webs.com/#38275>wholesale mac makeup</a> ,,http://clarisonicmia2us.webs.com/#18392 20:03, 1 March 2012 (EST)


Made a quick navigation bar for the new weapon skills - feel free to change it if you think it sucks. I thought we use some new icons as the previous ones were a little bit too oldschool hehe.

I subdivided some of the weapon set paged as was recommended and deleted the weapons from their quest pages as I don't think they should be listed there (see Isparian Weapons. I think it looks messy and it makes the weapon set pages kinda redundant also.

Thanks --Arkalor 14:45, 21 February 2012 (EST)

Edit: Icons with gold handles instead...

Template:Weapon Links 3

Edit: Changed them again - made more sense to just use the spell icons:


Weapons

Sets
 
Two Handed
 
Heavy
 
Light
 
Finesse
 
Missile
 
Magic Casters

--Arkalor 04:43, 2 March 2012 (EST)

The List

Add items here that are missing, and Complete after items that have been updated/created.

Here is a list of everything I can think of that will need to get updated:

Articles related to Item changes:

Articles related to Skill changes:


Page templates, wiki templates, misc

--An Adventurer 06:00, 25 January 2012 (EST)

In Progress

  • Weapon Mastery - Created, basic info from FAQ and forums added, needs specific effects added

Spells:

Completed

Skill Related

  • Attributes - Strength Coordination, and Quickness pages updated.

Skills:

Templates/Categories

Spells:

Articles related to Skill changes:

Character Creation:

  • Character Creation - Race/Heritage and Skills sections will need updating Complete - added the new Masteries and removed the old free skills.
  • Character Races Complete - added the new Masteries, removed the old free skills and the sister race skills
  • Character Templates - "Stock Templates" - updated, old ones archived.