User talk:An Adventurer: Difference between revisions
imported>Atarax No edit summary |
imported>Atarax No edit summary |
||
| Line 31: | Line 31: | ||
---- | ---- | ||
I ran into a couple inconsistencies with the banes. We have [[Blade Bane (Cantrip)]] and [[Lightning Bane (Cantrip)]], which match up with the [[Blade Bane (Spell)]] and [[Lightning Bane (Spell)]], however the cantrips are actually '''Major Slashing Bane''' and '''Major Storm Bane'''. (See [[Shield of Truth]]). The question is, should i leave the spell name as '''Lightning Bane (Cantrip)''' for consistency, or rename it to '''Storm Bane (Cantrip)'''? I'm thinking of just leaving it. | I ran into a couple inconsistencies with the banes. We have [[Blade Bane (Cantrip)]] and [[Lightning Bane (Cantrip)]], which match up with the [[Blade Bane (Spell)]] and [[Lightning Bane (Spell)]], however the cantrips are actually '''Major Slashing Bane''' and '''Major Storm Bane'''. (See [[Shield of Truth]]). The question is, should i leave the spell name as '''Lightning Bane (Cantrip)''' for consistency, or rename it to '''Storm Bane (Cantrip)'''? I'm thinking of just leaving it. --[[User:Atarax|Atarax]] 14:48, 23 February 2009 (CST) | ||
Revision as of 14:48, 23 February 2009
- PM An Adventurer on forums.ac.turbine - recommended way to PM me. I rarely check the others.
- PM An Adventurer on ACVault
- PM An Adventurer on CoD WarCry
Or leave a message below:
I made a few changes to your sandbox this morning, I'm not arguing for their inclusion, just making suggestions so please remove them if they don't fit. --Tlosk 08:12, 10 February 2009 (CST)
Do you think this Wisp Whipper quest, should be named in the proper Hunter Quest (Wisp Whipper) format? Was going to change it before too many articles link to it. --Atarax 11:01, 12 February 2009 (CST)
- I'm not a fan of the kill task titling either. I just figured you or Tlosk made up the naming schema for it, so I wanted to stick with the standards. We should probably end up using the "Title" that it gives as the quest name, or Title Kill Task or something like that. --Atarax 11:39, 12 February 2009 (CST)
I'm working on the Sandbox, trying to finish off the Cantrips section, but I ran into an issue. All the way down, I was using Skill Name (Cantrip) as my root page, however when I got to invuln, I noticed that I had already created a page for Invulnerability (Cantrip), where I should have created Melee Defense (Cantrip). So it got me to thinking, which one is correct?
I see that we have Invulnerability (Spell), and on one hand it would make sense to stick with this format, but on the other hand, for almost all the other skills like Axe (Cantrip), Lockpick (Cantrip), Alchemy (Cantrip), etc... there really is isn't any consistency, since the spell is Axe Mastery (Spell), etc...
Some of the conflicts that I've already created are:
- Loyalty (Cantrip), which could have been Fealty (Cantrip)
- Magic Defense (Cantrip), which could have been Magic Resistance (Cantrip)
- Run (Cantrip), which could have been Sprint (Cantrip)
Since there is no "negative" cantrip, I say lets just keep it Skill Name (Cantrip) to keep it consistent across the board. But I wanted to get your opinion before I went ahead and did anything. What do you think? --Atarax 16:01, 18 February 2009 (CST)
- Ok, well I'll leave it for now. However, if you think we should start over, I don't mind. But IMO it doesn't even matter because Axe Aptitude (Cantrip) doesn't directly correlate to Axe Mastery (Spell) either. I was wrong, there ARE negative cantrips. I mean, look at the Noble Armor page. It casts Ravenous Armor, which is a negative cantrip. So, the answer is to either keep it Skill Name (Cantrip), and include both positive and negative cantrips on one page, or separate them like you suggested and create Skill Name Mastery (Cantrip) and Skill Name Ineptitude (Cantrip). I think the "right" way is the latter, as you suggested, but since there are so few negative cantrips, I doubt its worth the effort. Any second thoughts before I just continue with Skill Name (Cantrip)? --Atarax 18:00, 18 February 2009 (CST)
I ran into a couple inconsistencies with the banes. We have Blade Bane (Cantrip) and Lightning Bane (Cantrip), which match up with the Blade Bane (Spell) and Lightning Bane (Spell), however the cantrips are actually Major Slashing Bane and Major Storm Bane. (See Shield of Truth). The question is, should i leave the spell name as Lightning Bane (Cantrip) for consistency, or rename it to Storm Bane (Cantrip)? I'm thinking of just leaving it. --Atarax 14:48, 23 February 2009 (CST)